Memglobal logo
Memglobal logo

Before We Play: The “New Jew” and Jewish Bodies in Sport 

By Annie Prusky, Jewish Life Specialist

INTRODUCTION:

A 20–25 minute source sheet and discussion for basketball night, football game watch party, etc. 

Goal: Before tonight’s game, we’re going to spend some time with a piece of Jewish history that’s still in the room every time we play: the long-running, centuries-old argument inside Jewish tradition over what a Jewish body and a Jewish man are supposed to be. We’ll start further back than you might expect — with a rabbinic ideal that prized the scholar over the soldier — then trace the 100-year-old project to flip that script into “Muscular Judaism,” sit with one critical take on what that project cost, meet an alternative model that pushed the other way, and think about where we each land as we head out to the court. 

Part 1: Before “New” — The Traditional “Soft Man” Ideal (8 min) 

Context: Before we talk about basketball, or strength, or anything “new” at all — let’s start with what came before. Scholar Daniel Boyarin has argued that for most of Jewish history, the ideal man in traditional Ashkenazi culture looked nothing like the muscular athlete many of us picture today. 

“Much of traditional Jewish culture distinguishes gender and gender roles very differently, setting up a passive, receptive male as its ideal, reserving active, aggressive roles, vis-a-vis the world, for women.” 
— Daniel Boyarin, quoted in Berkeley author deconstructs traditional Jewish gender roles, J. 

“While their men were sitting indoors and studying Torah, speaking only a Jewish language, and withdrawn from the world, women of the same class were speaking, reading, and writing the vernacular, maintaining businesses large and small, and dealing with the wide world of tax collectors and irate customers.” 
— Daniel Boyarin, quoted in J. 

Here’s the tension worth sitting with: was this “soft man” ideal an antisemitic stereotype, or something Jewish culture built on purpose — or both? 

“If anti-Jewish tropes had depicted European Jewish men as womanly, Boyarin claims that the feminized Jewish man was not an antisemitic invention: Jewish culture assertively created a form of Torah-centric ‘alternative gendering’ to distinguish itself from its surroundings.” 
— Francesca Bregoli, Jewish Masculinities, 1200–1800, Quest: Issues in Contemporary Jewish History 

“In Boyarin’s interpretation, the traditional Ashkenazi rabbinic ideal of the effeminate man, which in his view dominated from the Middle Ages through the nineteenth century, arose from ancient Talmudic interpretations that resisted Roman gender paradigms of active masculinity and passive femininity. The rabbis’ model posited instead a form of ‘gentle, timid, and studious’ masculinity defined in opposition to the warrior-like Christian trope popular in European romances.” 
— Francesca Bregoli, Jewish Masculinities, 1200–1800, Quest 

A complication worth naming: scholars caution against treating the “soft man” ideal as the whole story — or as simply passive. 

“The idea of the pre-modern ‘Jewish sissy’ publicized by Boyarin should be heavily corrected… Talmudic discourse undoubtedly did promote forms of intellectual, rather than physical, masculinity. Still, pace Boyarin, scholars of rabbinics have convincingly emphasized that the rabbis’ masculinity was articulated around violently agonistic, war-like notions of scholarly discipline and conflict.” 
— Francesca Bregoli, Jewish Masculinities, 1200–1800, Quest 

And it wasn’t the only model medieval Jewish men lived with. In Christian Europe, Jewish men were also drawn to a very different ideal: the knight. 

“[These young Jewish men] were navigating two masculinities, and… internalized complex identities, which enabled them to identify as Jews and at the same time to feel that they were part of mainstream urban culture to some degree.” 
— Eyal Levinson, Between Rabbinic and Knightly Masculinities: Constructing Gendered Identities Among Jewish Young Men in Medieval Ashkenaz, Quest 

Levinson’s research documents Jewish men jousting at their own weddings and identifying with knightly imagery, even while rabbinic culture prized the scholar over the soldier. 

Here’s the bridge to where we’re headed next: 

“The new Jewish male was similar to European ideals, big, strong, active as opposed to passive, aggressive, belligerent, aggressively involved in making a living, protecting his women folk, providing for them, self reliant, individualistic.” 
— Daniel Boyarin, quoted in J., contrasting the traditional ideal with Zionism’s vision 

Discussion questions: 

  1. For centuries, the “ideal” Jewish man in rabbinic and Haggadah tradition was the scholar, not the soldier — and Boyarin argues this wasn’t just an insult imposed by antisemites, but something Jewish culture built on its own terms. Does that surprise you? What do you make of the idea that it might be both a stereotype and a self-chosen value at the same time? 
  1. Levinson’s research suggests medieval Jewish men didn’t have to choose one masculinity over the other — they lived with both the rabbinic ideal and real admiration for knights at the same time. Where do you feel pulled between two different models of what a Jewish man (or person) “should” be? 
Part 2: The History — From “Weak” Stereotype to “Muscular Jew” — and What It Cost (10 min) 

Context: In 19th-century Europe, antisemitic stereotypes painted Jews as physically weak, pale, bookish, and unsuited to outdoor life. Zionist thinkers set out to deliberately rewrite that story. 

“Max Nordau, co-founder of the Zionist movement, believed the source of this crisis was the exile from the land of Israel… Nordau envisioned a Jewish rebirth grounded in strength and health and rooted in the land, coining the term ‘Muskeljudentum,’ or Muscular Judaism.” 
— From Muscle to Memory: The New Jew and the Physical Rebirth of Jewish Identity, Bud Shorstein Center for Jewish Studies 

“Many Jewish athletic associations were founded worldwide to support the growing recognition of Jewish athletic ability. Movements like Maccabi, established in 1929, cultivated a collective practice of sport, gymnastics and competitions… Bodily training became linked to the defense of settlements and the preparation for political independence.” 
— From Muscle to Memory, Bud Shorstein Center for Jewish Studies 

This wasn’t only an Israeli story. American Jews built their own version of it, especially in boxing: 

“American Jews’ success in boxing, a sport in which they were heavily represented, came to symbolize working- and lower-middle-class Jews’ determination to challenge antisemitism and, in the 1930s, Nazism. Their prowess in the ring helped undermine hoary stereotypes of Jewish males’ physical incapacity, cowardice, and effeminacy.” 
— Stephen H. Norwood, “American Jewish Muscle”: Forging a New Masculinity in the Streets and in the Ring, 1890–1940, Modern Judaism 

Why did this feel so urgent? Part of the answer is that the “weak” stereotype wasn’t just about bodies — it was medicalized. 

“Anti-Semitic rhetoric in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries often depicted the Diasporic Jewish character as nervous and weak, both physically and mentally… the assignment of nervousness to Jewish people, whether men or women, translated to an emasculation of Judaism as a whole.” 
— Rachel Byrne, Re-Masculinizing the Jew: Gender and Zionism Until the First World War, Gnovis Journal, Georgetown University 

One scholarly reading — not a consensus view, but a serious one worth sitting with — looks closely at *how* this re-masculinization happened, and what it was responding to: 

“Zionism sought to replace the effeminacy attributed to Jewish men with a masculinity defined by European gentiles… as a means to gain legitimacy from the very European nation-states that drove Jewish people out through anti-Semitic discrimination. The vehicles used to re-masculinize Jewish men include: socialism as seen with the kibbutzim… gymnastics and agriculture, and the induction of Jewish men into violent European culture through dueling and militarism.” 
— Rachel Byrne, Re-Masculinizing the Jew, Gnovis Journal 

It’s worth noting this wasn’t only about men. Byrne argues the shift reshaped expectations for women too, in a complicated way: 

“Secular, socialist Zionism sought to actively include women in the building of the Jewish state. Their roles shifted from housewife and mother to fieldworker and socialist, although motherhood remained a necessity in nation building. However… instead of women and men renegotiating and redistributing traditional gender roles, women adopted traditionally masculine roles in addition to traditionally feminine roles. Therefore, socialist Zionism sought to transform the Jewish people, both men and women, into more masculine subjects, rather than creating an organic equality through compromising both masculine and feminine gendered roles.” 
— Rachel Byrne, Re-Masculinizing the Jew, Gnovis Journal 

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS: 

  • Before tonight, had you heard of “Muscular Judaism” or the “New Jew”? Does knowing this history change how you think about Jews and sports — including your own relationship to being an athletic (or not-so-athletic) Jew? 
  • The Shorstein piece notes the original “New Jew” image was mostly male and tied to labor, land, and soldiering. Where do you see that legacy still showing up in Jewish life today — and where has it clearly loosened or changed? 
  • Byrne’s reading suggests the “New Jew” project was also about proving Jewish men could be “men like all other (European) men” — not just about individuals feeling stronger or healthier. Does that complicate the story above for you? How do you hold both the real experience of overcoming antisemitic stereotypes and a critical argument like this one at the same time? 
        Part 3: The Alternative — What About the “Nice Jewish Boy”? (4 min) 

        The “New Jew” wasn’t the only model of Jewish masculinity to emerge. Alongside — and partly in tension with — the muscular ideal, American Jewish culture also produced a very different archetype. 

        “Where toxic masculinity has promoted feats of physical strength, decisiveness, and violence, the Nice Jewish Boy is a well-defined masculine archetype prized for opposing characteristics.” 
        — Joshua Wolfsun, The Mainstream Misogyny of the Nice Jewish Boy, Lilith Magazine 

        DISCUSSION QUESTION: 

        • If the “New Jew” said Jewish men should be strong, athletic, and tough, the “Nice Jewish Boy” archetype represents almost the opposite — gentle, cerebral, unaggressive. Which of these models, if either, feels closer to how Jewish masculinity gets talked about in your own life or community? Is there a version of Jewish identity and sport tonight that doesn’t have to choose between “tough” and “nice”? 
        Closing Thought (2 min) 

        Tonight, we’re about to go play basketball — an activity that’s been part of this Jewish story of strength and body for over a century. That doesn’t mean we have to buy the whole package of what “Muscular Judaism” was trying to prove. As you head onto the court, see if you can notice: what does it feel like, for you personally, to be a Jewish body in motion tonight?