Memglobal logo
Memglobal logo

Hanukkah Rom-Com Night: Choose Your Own Adventure   

By Rabbi Shari Shamah, Jewish Life Specialist

INTRODUCTION:

During the holiday season, the Hallmark channel is known for feel good Christmas movies. In the past 5-10 years, that option has expanded to include kitchy Hanukkah movies as well. Add in the recent surge in Jewish rom-com books, and you have the makings of a comfy, cozy rom-com Hanukkah program. This program is designed to be a choose your own adventure, there are two books and a movie to choose from. 

PROGRAM OUTLINE (1-3 hours):

  • [part one] Intro to Jewish rom-coms 
  • [part two] Watch movie or book discussion 
  • [part three] Movie discussion or book closing 

MATERIALS:

  • For both options:  
    • A menorah and candles, if the gathering falls during Hanukkah itself 
    • Printed or shared discussion prompts for the chosen path 
  • Option A: Way to stream Eight Nights for Love (Hallmark Channel or Hallmark +) 
  • Option B: Pre-distributed copies of The Eight Heartbreaks of Hanukkah by Jean Meltzer 
  • Option C: Pre-distributed copies of Love you a Latke by Amanda Elliot 

[part one] 5 minutes

  • Intro: Hanukkah rom-coms are a pretty new thing. For decades, networks like Hallmark built an entire industry around Christmas romance — dozens of movies a year — while Hanukkah got, at most, a passing mention. That’s only recently started to change, with networks expanding their Hanukkah options and a wave of Jewish romance novelists writing Hanukkah-set love stories of their own.  
  • That matters how we watch/read tonight. A bad Christmas movie barely gets a passing nod — there are a hundred others out there.  A Hanukkah rom com doesn’t have that luxury yet; for some viewers or readers, it might be one of the only mainstream pictures of the holiday they ever see. So, as we go tonight, it’s worth paying attention to what makes it onto the page or screen and the impression that we’re left with. 

[part two] 1-2 hrs 

Option A: Watch Eight Nights for Love premiering November 29 on the Hallmark Channel.  Hannah works for a large auction house in New York City and is excited for her best friend Ethan to return home for a visit during Hanukkah. She meets the mysterious Pearl, who gifts her an antique menorah that takes her back to a different time in her life each night of Hanukkah, with Pearl as her guide — leading Hannah to reflect, break out of her comfort zone, and overcome her fear of failure, while her feelings for Ethan resurface. 

  • Discussion Questions: 
    • The movie uses a magical menorah to revisit a different night from Hannah’s past each night of Hanukkah. Did the movie’s version of “looking back” feel connected to real Hanukkah themes of memory, or more like a romance device that just borrowed the number eight? 
    • What’s one moment that felt like real Hanukkah, and one that felt like generic “holiday movie” dressing? 
    • Hannah has to overcome her fear of failure across the eight nights. Did you buy the connection between her small, personal growth and the idea of something small (one night of oil) becoming bigger than expected? 
    • Are there emotions triggered by watching a Jewish movie on tv?  
    • How is Hanukkah portrayed? Accurate?  
    • What cringe moments did you have watching this? 

Option B: Read and Discuss the Eight Heartbreaks of Hanukkah by Jean Meltzer 

Jean Meltzer, is known for centering Jewish characters and practice with real specificity. She has written five Jewish rom-coms and has another one on the way. In this book, literary agent Hannah Rosen who is in the midst of a career crisis, returns home to spend Hanukkah with her large, bickering Jewish family — only to be reunited with her ex-boyfriend, pulling her back into old feelings and even older family drama. 

  • Discussion Questions:  
    • Hannah’s homecoming is full of family chaos and an ex-boyfriend she’s not over. How did the book use Hanukkah specifically — as backdrop, or as something that actually shapes what happens in the family? 
    • Jean Meltzer is known for writing Jewish characters and practice with real specificity. Where did you feel that most? Where did it feel thinner? 
    • Hanukkah is a holiday about rededication — reclaiming and recommitting to something. Does Hannah rededicate herself to anything by the end — family, home, herself, love? 
    • Any cringe moments while you read? 
    • How do you feel reading Jewish rom com lit?  
    • Are there parts of the book you’d change? 

Option C: Read and Discuss Love You a Latke by Amanda Elliot. This is one of four Jewish rom-coms that Amanda Elliot has written, and each includes an element of food in the love story. Abby Cohen is roped into judging the Latke Festival in her Vermont hometown, working alongside her former childhood best friend and now celebrity chef Seth Evans, with whom she has a messy romantic history. 

  • Discussion Questions: 
    • The whole plot centers on a Latke Festival. Food is genuinely central to Hanukkah (oil marking the miracle). Did the book’s use of latkes feel like it understood why that food matters, or mostly use it as a cute setting? 
    • Abby and Seth have old, messy history in a small Jewish hometown community. What did the book get right (or not) about what that kind of tight-knit community feels like? 
    • What’s one detail from the book you want to steal for your own latkes this year? 
    • Any cringe moments as you read? 
    • If you were choosing another element of Hanukkah to base a book around, what would it be? 

[part three] 5 minutes

  • Closing: take a quick thumbs up/thumbs down on Hanukkah rom-coms, or the book/movie you just went through? If you were going to write or create a Jewish rom com, what would it be?  
  • Share other book/movie recommendations.